Introduction
In Chief Executive of the Department of Environment and Science v NuGrow Ipswich Pty Ltd (No 2) [2026] QPEC 37, the Queensland Planning and Environment Court confirmed that it can vary a restraint order under s 505 of the Environmental Protection Act 1994 (Qld), and explained why a missed deadline alone will not be enough to do so.
The Facility and Odour Nuisance
NuGrow operated a large waste recycling and compost manufacturing facility at Swanbank, Ipswich. Making compost meant receiving, storing and mixing odoriferous material, and the Court noted there was a genuine risk of odour nuisance, particularly in the early stages of composting.
In December 2023, the Chief Executive of the Department of Environment and Science commenced proceedings under s 505 of the EP Act. The aim was to restrain NuGrow from causing unlawful odour nuisance (an offence under s 440(2)) and to compel it to build and use an approved in-vessel composting system. After an unsuccessful application for interim orders, the Court recorded on 12 April 2024 that it was satisfied an offence of odour nuisance would be committed unless restrained by orders requiring an enclosed or engineered composting system.
The Final Order and Staged Transition
The parties then agreed on terms, and the Court made a “final order” on 18 September 2024, which had two moving components. First, NuGrow was restrained from receiving certain “Listed waste” notorious for odour. Second, that restraint was stayed so long as NuGrow transitioned to better systems: first a Mobile Aerated Floor System (MAF System), then an Engineered Membrane System, and finally an In-Vessel System (IVS) (an enclosed system that contains odour within impervious tunnels).
In 2025, after a design process, NuGrow decided to drop the membrane stage and deliver an IVS alone, on an expedited timetable. By consent, the order was amended on 2 May 2025 (the Amended Final Order, or AFO). By 18 September 2026, NuGrow had to have the IVS installed, commissioned and in use. NuGrow’s Executive General Manager, Mr Wilson, accepted that delivering 12 permanent concrete and steel tunnels in that time was “achievable” but “tight”. NuGrow’s environmental authority mirrored that date.
Why the Deadline Slipped
The project, costing $29 million, was substantially advanced by early September 2026. Foundations and earthworks were complete, aeration pipework was in, and walls had been built for nine of the 12 tunnels. However, it would not be completed on time. The Court accepted four coalescing causes: late issued-for-construction design information (not finalised until 31 July 2026); design deficiencies identified by the principal contractor; long-lead procurement delays beyond NuGrow’s control; and delays to critical-path stage 2 earthworks.
NuGrow told the Department on 25 June 2026 that the date would be missed and offered a staged delivery, which the Department declined. NuGrow’s responses to later information requests were slow, which the Court treated as relevant to the discretion. On 4 September 2026 NuGrow applied to move the date to 21 January 2027. This date was treated as the “worst case”, with evidence being submitted that it may be possible to finish works as early as 6 January. The Department had signalled it would work with NuGrow on consequential amendments to the environmental authority, but on 17 September it reversed course and opposed the application.
The Power to Amend the AFO
Section 505 does not expressly allow a restraint order to be changed or cancelled. The Chief Executive argued the power lay elsewhere, in r 7 (extending time) or r 668 (matters arising after an order) of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999, relying on Crowther v State of Queensland [2005] QCA 47, where r 668 supported an order giving more time to remedy a nuisance.
Williamson KC DCJ accepted there was “considerable force” in that submission, but thought it premature to turn to the UCPR before asking whether the power arises in the EP Act itself. His Honour found that it does, for a combination of reasons:
- Section 505(5) confers a broad discretion, and s 505(6)(b) allows orders “in the terms the Court considers appropriate”, so restraint orders are inherently flexible and can carry ongoing conditions.
- Despite its title, the “final order” was not spent. It operates into the future, so the Court’s supervisory role is incomplete.
- Statutory silence is not prohibition. A power given to a court can carry incidental powers needed to exercise it, subject to the same precondition in s 505(5), which remained satisfied.
- Reading in a limitation would offend the principle, stated by Gaudron J in Knight v FP Special Assets Ltd, that a grant of power to a court should not be construed as subject to a limitation not appearing in its words.
The Court acknowledged that earlier decisions had located the power in r 668, but noted that those courts were not taken to this reasoning or to Knight. Notably, the Court contrasted s 181(4) of the Planning Act 2016, which expressly lets a person apply to change an enforcement order.
Reasons the AFO Should be Changed
Williamson KC DCJ gave the following reasons as to why the AFO should be changed.
- (1) – The delay and consequential need for the change was due to a range of design, procurement, and construction issues (note: there was no single factor that could be attributable to the delay, some of which, but not all, were beyond NuGrow’s control).
- (2) – NuGrow had gone to considerable effort to comply with the AFO, as seen through:
- The value of the works completed in September 2026 (+ $5 million);
- The work recorded as ‘completed’ in the construction programmes in evidence before the Court; and
- A number of aerial photographs that permit the sequence of construction work to be followed over the course of the past few months.
- (3) – NuGrow was committed to completing the IVS and there was no suggestion that the work undertaken thus far would be demolished.
- (4) – The change sought to the AFO would not appreciably increase the risk of odour nuisance beyond the boundaries of the NuGrow facility.
Importantly, though deserving of consideration, reasons (1) to (4) alone were not sufficient in showing that the AFO should be changed. This was because they were foreseeable and in consenting to the order, NuGrow assumed the foreseeable risk that works required to comply with the AFO may be substantially progressed but not complete by September 2026. The following reason, in addition to those outlined above, gave force behind changing the AFO:
- (5) – Dismissing the application would have significant and adverse consequences i.e. by not extending the In-Vessel System Date in paragraph 2, the AFO will no longer control the transition to the IVS, which is at odds with the order of 12 April 2024.
Conclusion
Thus, Williamson KC DCJ allowed the change to the application sought by NuGrow, subject to conditions.
This publication is general in nature. Its content is current at the date of publication. It does not constitute legal advice and you should always seek legal advice based on your particular circumstances prior to making any decisions relating to matters covered by this publication. Certain details may have been sourced from external references, and we cannot assure the accuracy or timeliness of such information.