In Van Wijik & Anor v Noosa Shire Council [2026] QPEC 38, Noosa Shire Council (Council) sought an application for an appeal to be struck out. Specifically, Council argued that the Appellants had no right to appeal as there had not been a ‘decision’ for which an appeal could be made against. The Planning and Environment Court dismissed this application.
Factual Background
The Appellants were land owners of land situated at 8 Witta Circle, Noosa Heads, which was improved with a dwelling house. The Appellants had obtained a conditional approval from Council under Noosa Shire Council Local Law No. 1 (Administration) 2015 and Subordinate Local Law No. 1 (Administration) 2015 (the local law)to use the house for short stay letting.
However, whilst operating short stay letting on the land, the Appellants received multiple complaints. In response, Council decided that an amendment of the approval was necessary to prevent loss of amenity under s 17(a)(ii) of the local law. Council gave a show cause notice (as required under s 18 of the local law) to the Appellants which set out the proposed amendments and the facts and circumstances being relied upon.
The Appellants opposed the amendments for reasons such as the insufficiency of Council’s evidence and the unreasonableness of the proposed conditions (the impugned conditions). However, Council decided to amend the approval to include the impugned conditions. This decision was communicated via an ‘Amended Approval’ (the Original decision), which was accompanied by an information notice with reasons for the decision.
Under s 22(1) of the local law, the Appellants exercised their right to apply to the Chief Executive for a review of the Original decision. Council subsequently reviewed and confirmed the Original decision (the Confirmation decision) for the reasons given in the prior information notice. The Appellants then filed a notice of appeal.
Details of the Appeal
The appeal stated that the proceedings commenced under s 299 of the Planning Act 2016 (the PA), which refers to Schedule 1 of the PA. The Appellants sought an order that the Confirmation decision be set aside and replaced with a new decision that would not
impose the impugned conditions on the approval. Specifically, the Appellants relied on the appeal right under Schedule 1, Table 2, Item 6, which states:
An appeal may be made against a decision of local government, or conditions applied, under a local law about … the use of premises, other than a use that is the natural and ordinary consequence of prohibited development.
…
The appellant is a person who … applied for the decision; and is dissatisfied with the decision or conditions
Importantly, the term ‘decision’ is not defined within the PA.
The Legal Issue
Council argued the following:
- The Confirmation decision was not ‘a decision’ for the purpose of Schedule 1, Table 2, Item 6 of the PA;
- The Original decision was a ‘decision’ for the purpose of Schedule 1, Table 2, Item 6 of the PA because it was ‘confirmed’ by review, and remains operative; and
- No appeal right arose for the Original decision because it was not one the Appellants ‘applied for’, for the purpose of Schedule 1, Table 2, Item 6 of the PA.
Williamson KC DCJ accepted both (b) and (c) to be correct, but this was not determinative of the strike out application. Thus, the key issue surrounded (a) and whether the Confirmation decision was a decision.
The Court’s Reasoning
Williamson KC DCJ held that the confirmation decision was in fact a decision and gave six main reasons.
Firstly, the term ‘decision’ is not defined in the PA, as mentioned above. Thus, it should be given its plain and ordinary meaning, as per the rules of statutory interpretation. It was clear the Confirmation decision fit within this plain and ordinary meaning.
Secondly there is no context in the PA that provides that the term ‘decision’ ought to be given a narrower definition than the plain and ordinary meaning, as to exclude the Confirmation decision.
Thirdly, it was necessary for the Court to consider the local law in order to ascertain whether the Confirmation decision was a ‘decision’ for the purposes of the statutory instrument. Within the local law, there are several provisions that establish that the Confirmation decision to be a ‘decision’, the most compelling point being that the Confirmation decision, for the purposes of s 23(1) of the local law, would be a particular type of decision.
Fourthly, just because the Confirmation decision was not an operative decision such as the Original decision, it does not follow that the Confirmation decision ceased to be a decision
for the purposes of the local law. Neither the express words nor statutory context of the PA or local law indicate that the consequences flowing from the exercise of the decision-making power should be considered when identifying a decision.
Fifthly, the cases which Council relied on, Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond and Chief Executive of Environment and Heritage Protection v Alphadale Pty Ltd, did not assist in the determination of this issue. This is because they did not address the PA or local law, nor did they identify principles of general application about the proper construction of a legislative provision conferring an appeal right.
Sixthly, even if there was ambiguity regarding the appeal right, the Court considered and applied the reasoning in Buck v Comcare, which involved a statutory right to compensation which was assumed to be cancelled by legislative provision. Applying Buck, Schedule 1, Table 2, Item 6 of the PA confers an appeal right, and is enlivened by having regard to its plain and ordinary meaning. The right is engaged in circumstances where a unilateral decision has been made by Council to amend an existing approval in a way that interferes with the use of private property; and the decision interfering with the use of private property has been confirmed. Here, both of these elements were satisfied.
The Decision
Thus, the appeal right was able to be invoked as it was competent and within the Court’s jurisdiction. Council’s application to strike out the appeal was dismissed.
A Note on This Update
This article is a general summary and is not legal advice. We can advise clients on their appeal rights under the PA.
This publication is general in nature. Its content is current at the date of publication. It does not constitute legal advice and you should always seek legal advice based on your particular circumstances prior to making any decisions relating to matters covered by this publication. Certain details may have been sourced from external references, and we cannot assure the accuracy or timeliness of such information.